Is It Cake? 10 Episode Themes That Should Be Done In Season 2

is it cake has quickly grown into one of the most unique baking shows happening right now. Instead of the usual baking show format of just trying to make delicious desserts, this show adds an element of guesswork and suspense by hiding which cakes are real cakes and which are scams. Each episode has a unifying theme to tie all of the episode’s cakes together.

RELATED: Every Baking & Cooking show is coming to Netflix in 2022 (so far).

Having a good theme is extremely important as a good theme leads to more complicated cakes that will grab viewers’ attention. Seeing cakes designed as things no one would ever guess a cake would make the viewing experience that much funnier, and with only eight episodes of the show currently airing, there are plenty of untapped themes that make for standout episodes could worry.

10 Sports

Is it cake cone cake

Season 1 of is it cake tried his hand at sports themed cakes by having a bowling pin cake created in episode 6, but that episode was built around a flea market theme. Since sports and reality TV go well together, and seeing how good the skittle cake was, making the show a potentially fun idea with a dedicated sports episode.

Obvious cake designs could include some of the different balls used such as: a football or soccer ball, but more intriguing ones could be a baseball glove, boxing gloves, or pads. You could also take inspiration from the shoe that emerged in the second installment of the series, but make a shoe instead.

9 headgear

Hat cake from is it cake

Another fresh take on a theme that was explored somewhat in Season 1 is an episode dedicated to cakes with things to wear on your head; which could also produce some great designed deserts. Whether it’s something more conventional like a baseball hat or bucket hat, or something with more room for creativity like a crown or helmet, panelists would surely have fun guessing what cake is.

Episode 2 of the show featured a piece of clothing and a bowler hat. While this theme might not be entirely original, the opportunities the theme offers can make it a worthwhile one.


8th restaurant dishes

Designing cakes based on other foods has consistently resulted in some of the best cakes ever baked is it cake, so another episode that fully embraces it should be a great one of all time. The very first episode of the series focused on fast food, and other episodes featured grocery stores and party food, leaving fully realized dishes uncharted territory.

Johnny Manganello, one of the bakers who starred in Season 1, has an example on his Instagram account. His spaghetti and meatball cake looks phenomenal and shows the potential another food episode could have.

7 electronics

Radio cake on is cake

Season 1’s Flea Market episode (episode 6) had an antique radio cake to showcase a piece of outdated technology, so it’s certainly time to bring the show into the future with an episode about modern technology. Imagine seeing an iPhone cake? Or a game console?

RELATED: The best food shows on Netflix that don’t involve cake

The show is based on a popular internet meme, after all, so it might as well be an episode that appeals to the demographic the show is trying to reach. Having a VR headset pie might be a lot more interesting to a Gen Zer than an antique radio.

6 toiletries

Speaking of the memes that inspired the show, the original viral tweet that blew up the cheat cake trend featured plenty of household items like soap and toilet paper. These cakes looked exactly like the items they imitated, which is what caused the trend to take off so much. The Netflix series could go back to the basics of its origins and create an episode with those elements.

While these items could be considered grocery items, an episode theme already explored, this episode only featured groceries. These leave the door open for a bit of Redux, but with a brand new take.

5 public holidays

Challah bread it's cake

A lot of the best TV show episodes have holiday themes, so there’s no reason for that is it cake cannot join the party with their own variant. Usually people think of the holidays at the end of each year when holiday episodes happen, however is it cake could certainly get creative and involve others.

Christmas presents, menorahs, dreidels, and mistletoe would all be good choices for the most popular holidays, while you could also go the more reliable route and choose a dish like stuffed turkey for Thanksgiving. You could also show some love for St. Patrick’s Day and Halloween with things like a pot of gold or a jack-o’-lantern. This would be a totally original idea, since no existing episodes covered anything that would really fit into this category, except perhaps challah bread, a popular dish for many holidays celebrated in the Jewish faith.

4 music

Mikey Day on Is It Cake

On a topic, the show’s host Mikey Day might know a thing or two from his time live on saturday night, A musical cake episode would also be an entirely new theme, with no particular reference to previously made cakes.

Since the obvious design options are different instruments, things like a microphone or turntable could fill in the episode to add some variety. Since the show also features celebrity guest judges, the theme could be complemented with some who are involved in the music industry in one way or another.

3 baking equipment and accessories

Justin from Is it cake

is it cake could lean into a meta angle by being a baking show and having cakes that resemble the same items used to make them. Imagine seeing cakes that look like electronic whisks, frosted jars, spatulas, or cake tins?

Meta comedy and movies/TV episodes have always been fan favorites, and famous actor and a frequent subject of memes, Nicolas Cage just got his own meta movie, and fans have been clamoring for other actors to get their own meta movies. Reality and competition shows are limited in what they can do as they are inherently designed to be aware that they are being watched, but this is the best the show could achieve.

2 Hollywood

Hemus statuette cake from is it cake

The series will eventually air on Netflix, a streaming service known for producing a wealth of original content, including is it cake The series is also set in Los Angeles, the city where Hollywood is located, so going with a Hollywood theme would be quite fitting.

RELATED: Where to Follow the Best is it cake Baker on Instagram

Whether it’s something related to the movie industry, like an old camera, or something specifically Hollywood-related, like a Hollywood star, the possibilities for this theme would be endless. Netflix should also know a thing or two about this region, so their ideas should be unique.

1 Netflix Originals props

Orange Julius from Stranger Things

Echoing the benefit the show has of being produced by Netflix, is it cake may integrate some of the other shows being produced under the expansive Netflix umbrella. Imagine how cool it would be to use some props or iconic items from shows such as stranger things, Squid Gameand Orange is the new black.

Examples could be the orange Julius mugs featured on the fan favorite show stranger thingsor the menacing face coverings seen on Squid Game. Not only would it make some really epic looking cakes, but it would help promote other shows that deserve it and bring in some potential new fans from the shows featured in the episode.

NEXT: The 10 Best TV Shows Like Netflix is it cake

Images from the films Consuming Spirits, Fantastic Planet and Yellow Submarine.

The 10 Weirdest Animated Movies of All Time

About the author

Leave a Comment